The USDA Diaries (3): House Hunting With a USDA Direct Loan

House Hunting With a USDA Direct Loan

On finding the right realtor, surviving delayed negotiations, and learning to play a different game

THE USDA DIARIES · PART THREE

Catch up on the series: Part One  ·  Part Two

Getting preapproved for a mortgage and successfully buying a house are, as it turns out, two entirely different activities. By the time I started house hunting with my USDA Direct loan, I understood my approval. I understood the taxes. I had a spreadsheet. Obviously.

What I did not know yet was whether anyone would actually sell me a house.

USDA Direct came with some incredible advantages for me as a buyer, but it also came with complications. The house had to be in an eligible rural area. The property had to meet USDA requirements. My maximum loan amount changed depending on the property's taxes and insurance. And then there was the part that couldn't be calculated on a spreadsheet at all: sellers had to be willing to accept my financing.

The Realtor: Mike Number One

When I first started looking, I found a realtor named Mike. I told him I needed someone familiar with USDA, and he sounded confident. He contacted Samantha, my USDA specialist, directly to find out exactly what we were working with. I signed a consent form allowing USDA to discuss my loan with him, and he talked to her about the specifications of my approval and the kinds of properties that would work.

Then he set up an automated listing search for me. There was one unusual part: I would only receive houses after they had already been on the market for seven days.

At first, that seemed backward. In a competitive market, aren't you supposed to see houses immediately? Get there before everyone else? Make the offer before twelve other people do? But that was exactly the point.

A house that had survived its first week on the market was less likely to be headed into a giant bidding war. If it had been listed with delayed negotiations, that deadline might already have passed. The initial rush of buyers had already had their chance. A seller who still had a house to sell might be more willing to consider an offer with USDA financing.

It was a strategy built around not competing where I was least competitive, and it made sense.

Eventually, though, I stopped hearing from him. I don't know exactly why. Maybe he got busy. Maybe my search was more complicated than it was worth. USDA Direct does add extra moving pieces to a house search, and I understood from the beginning that I wasn't necessarily going to be the easiest buyer in someone's client list.

Whatever the reason, I needed another realtor.

Then There Was Mike Number Two

I found the second Mike completely by accident. I had requested showings for a couple of houses through Zillow, and he was the realtor who got assigned to me. I liked him almost immediately.

I also warned him almost immediately. I explained that I was using USDA Direct, that my financing had some unusual requirements, and that I wasn't even sure he would want to take me on as a client. USDA financing can make people nervous, and I knew I needed someone who was willing to work with it.

He was.

He didn't need to walk into the relationship knowing every detail of Section 502 Direct. What mattered was that he was willing to learn what applied to me, ask questions when necessary, and work within the parameters USDA had given us. That turned out to matter much more than finding someone who could recite the USDA handbook from memory.

Finding an Eligible House Was Only the Beginning

USDA Direct is a rural housing program, so the first question was whether a house was in an eligible area. But "rural" does not necessarily mean a farmhouse surrounded by seventy acres and cows. USDA has its own geographic eligibility rules, and there were plenty of houses in villages and small communities that could qualify.

Location was only the first test. The house itself also had to work for USDA.

USDA Direct has property requirements intended to make sure the home is decent, safe, sanitary, and structurally sound. That meant condition mattered. A house could be cheap enough, have manageable taxes, be in an eligible area, and still raise questions because of the property itself.

So every listing became a little checklist: is the location eligible? What are the taxes? What does that do to my maximum loan? Does the house appear to be in acceptable condition? Is there anything obvious that could become a USDA problem? And, assuming all of those answers were good: do I actually want to live there?

Turns out buying a house is slightly more complicated than finding one with a cute porch.

Then We Entered the Bidding Wars Anyway

Despite the very sensible seven-day strategy Mike Number One had created, Mike Number Two and I initially did what everyone else in a competitive housing market was doing. We went after the houses everyone wanted.

The first house I loved went into delayed negotiations. I made an offer with an escalation clause that could take me substantially over asking price. In the end, there were six offers, and mine wasn't the one they chose. There were higher offers with easier financing than USDA.

Then came another house. The Hilton house. It was listed at $189,900, and again there were delayed negotiations. I made another aggressive offer. The sellers came back wanting substantially more money, and the whole thing dragged on longer than it should have, with discussions about what it would take to make the deal happen.

I eventually raised my maximum offer in our escalation clause from $232,000 to $235,000. They wanted around $250,000. I said no, and they took another offer.

Two houses. Two delayed-negotiation situations. Two losses. At that point, it became increasingly obvious that simply throwing myself into the same frenzy as every conventional and cash buyer was probably not going to be my best strategy.

USDA Wasn't Always the Reason I Lost

It would have been very easy to blame USDA every time I didn't get a house. Sometimes USDA financing can make a seller nervous. A conventional offer may look simpler. A cash offer can look even simpler than that. USDA has property requirements, an appraisal process, and its own procedures. A seller looking at several otherwise similar offers may prefer one that appears to have fewer potential complications.

But USDA wasn't necessarily why I lost those first two houses. One had multiple offers, including extremely strong ones. The other seller wanted more money than I was willing to pay.

That wasn't a USDA problem. That was a housing-market problem.

My financing affected the way I competed, but it didn't explain every rejection. Sometimes another buyer simply had a better offer. Sometimes a seller wanted a number I wasn't willing to reach. And sometimes the smartest thing I could do was stop trying to win.

Maybe We Needed a Different Game

After two attempts at competing for the houses everyone else wanted, Mike and I started changing the way we looked. We paid more attention to older listings. Not necessarily old houses, but houses that had been sitting on the market longer.

We looked at listings that had survived their delayed-negotiation dates. Houses that had already had their big debut on Zillow, already accumulated their saves, already had their weekend showings, and were somehow still there.

Essentially, we circled back to the strategy Mike Number One had understood from the beginning. Maybe the goal wasn't to win the bidding war. Maybe the goal was to find the house where there wasn't one.

For me, that was a much better position. A seller with six offers can afford to be picky about financing. A seller whose house is still available after everyone has already had a chance to see it may be more interested in the fact that you are a qualified buyer who genuinely wants the house.

We needed strategy, not just a bigger number.

And Then There Was North Street

The house that eventually became ours had already passed its delayed-negotiation date when I found it. It was still active.

The asking price was $234,900. It had four bedrooms (five if you count the den), enough space for the three of us, a deck out back, a yard, and an upstairs laundry room that immediately made me start imagining a future second bathroom.

Most importantly, the first time I walked through it, I felt something I hadn't felt in the other houses: This is supposed to be ours.

So we made an offer. I offered $230,000.

And then USDA became an issue. The seller's realtor was concerned about my financing. This was exactly the kind of thing I had worried about when I first met Mike and essentially warned him that I might be a pain in the ass to represent.

But this time, I had a realtor who was willing to deal with it. Mike addressed their concerns and explained the financing.

Then there was another complication that had nothing to do with USDA: it was an estate, and the family was having a difficult time letting go of a home their mother had owned for decades.

Eventually, they came back with a counteroffer: full asking price. I agreed.

The next morning, Mike texted me at work: “Pls call me when free - good news.”

They had accepted. With USDA Direct financing.

The Offer I Won Wasn't the Highest One I Made

There was something almost absurd about the progression. On the first house, I was willing to escalate tens of thousands of dollars over asking and lost. On the second, I went more than $40,000 over its $189,900 list price and lost again.

Then I found a house that had already survived delayed negotiations, offered $230,000 on a $234,900 listing, agreed to the seller's full-price counter, and got it.

Same buyer. Same USDA financing. Completely different circumstances.

The difference wasn't that I had suddenly become a stronger buyer. It was that we had finally found a situation where my offer didn't have to beat a pile of other offers to survive.

That is probably the biggest thing I learned about house hunting with USDA Direct.

You Need the Right Realtor. And You Need a Strategy.

I don't think every USDA Direct buyer necessarily needs a realtor who already knows every detail of the program. I do think you need one who is willing to work with it. Someone who understands that your maximum may change from house to house. Someone willing to communicate with USDA when necessary. Someone who pays attention to property condition. Someone who isn't going to panic the first time a listing agent hears "USDA" and gets nervous.

And depending on your market, you may need to think differently about which houses you pursue. I spent part of my search trying to compete head-on with buyers who had conventional financing, cash, bigger deposits, fewer contingencies, or simply more money. Eventually, we stopped chasing only the newest, hottest listings and started looking harder at the houses everyone else had already passed over.

One of them was ours.

USDA Direct didn't make it impossible for me to buy a house. It did make the search more complicated. It narrowed some options. It added calculations. It occasionally made sellers nervous. And it meant that Mike and I had to think strategically about where my offer had the best chance of being taken seriously.

But after weeks of wondering whether anyone would actually sell me a house, I finally had an accepted offer.

Not despite having USDA Direct. With it.

I'm documenting my personal experience with the USDA Section 502 Direct Loan Program in New York in 2026. This is not financial, lending, or legal advice. Program rules, income limits, funding availability, payment assistance, processing times, property requirements, and individual circumstances can change. Always verify current requirements directly with USDA Rural Development.

It’s Only Seventy-Five Dollars

On questionable arithmetic, extraordinary bargains, and the financial consequences of Facebook Marketplace


I am exceptionally careful with money.


I track my savings. I monitor my debt. I compare prices. I research purchases. I know approximately how much money I have, how much money I owe, and how much money I can reasonably afford to spend. I have spreadsheets. I have budgets. I have financial goals.


And then I see an antique chair, and suddenly the budget becomes a philosophical concept.


“It’s only seventy-five dollars,” I tell myself.


This is a phrase I have repeated with increasing frequency over the past several months. Sometimes it’s fifty dollars. Sometimes it’s a hundred. Occasionally, it’s considerably more, but I’ve usually negotiated the price down, which makes it feel as though I’ve somehow earned money.


I recognize that this is not how economics works. I am choosing not to dwell on it.


For the past several months, I’ve been preparing to furnish an entire house. Not just a few rooms, either. An actual house, with multiple bedrooms, two living areas, a dining room, and a library. And because I have a lifelong love of antique furniture, I have been purchasing almost everything secondhand.


This isn’t a new interest. I’ve always loved old things. The craftsmanship, the details, the history, the sense that something has already lived an entire life before finding its way into mine. What’s new is the scale of my ambition.


Previously, I might have admired a beautiful antique dresser and wondered where I could put it. Now I have an entire house to furnish. This has proven to be a dangerous amount of freedom. Facebook Marketplace has become less of an app and more of a second occupation. Every day, somewhere in Western New York, someone lists a piece of furniture.


And I am there.


I have become remarkably efficient at this process. I can identify a promising listing, estimate its dimensions, assess its condition, research its approximate value, calculate the driving distance, and formulate an offer in a matter of minutes.


I have also developed a very specific negotiating style. I am polite. I am enthusiastic. I am absolutely going to ask whether they would consider less.


Someone lists a dresser for $150. I offer $90. They counter with $120. I offer $100. They accept.


I have saved fifty dollars.


This is how I explain the transaction to myself. The fact that I have also spent a hundred dollars is a secondary consideration.


Sometimes the savings are even more impressive. A seller reduces the price before I’ve made an offer. I negotiate further. Eventually, I purchase something for a fraction of its original asking price. I feel victorious. I feel financially responsible. I feel as though I have personally defeated inflation. Never mind that I was not planning to purchase the item until approximately forty-five minutes earlier. The important thing is that I got a deal.


Of course, purchasing secondhand furniture introduces certain logistical complications. For one thing, the furniture is rarely located anywhere convenient. I live in Western New York, which means that a perfectly lovely antique dresser may be available in Greece, Geneseo, Bethany, or some other town that requires an increasingly elaborate transportation strategy.


I have spent a surprising amount of time calculating routes between strangers’ houses. At this point, I am essentially operating a small furniture transportation company.


Without employees. Or a truck. Or a business license.


Fortunately, I have my aunt and her truck.


She has become my most reliable accomplice in this increasingly elaborate operation. Together, we have traveled to strangers’ homes, evaluated furniture, and attempted to determine how to transport objects that were clearly not designed with modern compact vehicles in mind. I suspect that when I first mentioned furnishing the new house, she did not anticipate becoming an unpaid logistics coordinator for a woman with an antique furniture problem.


But here we are.


A simple furniture pickup can require multiple people, measuring tapes, moving blankets, and a detailed discussion about whether something will fit through the back of my small SUV. I have asked whether dressers will fit. Whether fireplaces will fit. Whether chairs will fit. I have developed a relationship with vehicle dimensions that I never anticipated having.


And occasionally, the answer is no.


This is deeply disappointing, because I have generally already imagined where the furniture will go.


I have also begun considering a new strategy.


Eventually, I will need to rent a moving truck. A large one. And since I will already be paying for the truck, it seems only sensible to maximize its usefulness. Which means that I am now contemplating purchasing several larger pieces of antique furniture and arranging to pick them up during the first day or two of my move. I recognize that most people rent a moving truck to transport belongings they already own. I am apparently considering using mine to acquire additional belongings.


There is a certain efficiency to this plan. There is also the possibility that I will spend moving day driving around Western New York collecting furniture from strangers while my actual possessions remain in boxes.


But think of the savings!


There is also the matter of storage. I have been purchasing furniture for a house I do not yet own. This is an important detail. The closing process has been prolonged, unpredictable, and at times deeply frustrating. But apparently, I have decided that the appropriate response to uncertainty is to continue purchasing furniture. If the federal government cannot give me a closing date, perhaps I can at least secure a matching pair of antique lamps.


It gives me something to control. Or, at the very least, something to negotiate.


And the purchases have begun accumulating. A dresser here. A chair there. A table. A mirror. A lamp. Another dresser. Each purchase is entirely reasonable when considered individually.


Collectively, they suggest that I may have lost control of the situation.


But I prefer to think of it as progress. I am furnishing a house. Furniture is necessary. Therefore, buying furniture is responsible. This is the foundation of my current financial philosophy. It does become slightly more difficult to defend when the item in question is an antique decorative object whose primary purpose is to look beautiful.


But beauty has value. History has value. Character has value. And if I can obtain all three for forty dollars, I believe that should count as sound financial planning.


I have also become extraordinarily skilled at justifying purchases through comparison. A new dresser might cost $600. I found an antique one for $100. Therefore, I saved $500. A new dining room set might cost $2,000. I found a secondhand one for a few hundred dollars. At this rate, I should be a millionaire.


Unfortunately, my bank account has not yet recognized these accomplishments.


I have also discovered that a purchase becomes considerably easier to justify when I divide the cost by the number of pieces included. A bedroom set for $300 sounds expensive. But if it includes a bed, two dressers, and a mirror, that’s practically four separate bargains. And if I negotiate the price down?


Well. I might as well be receiving a government grant.


There is also the curious phenomenon of the purchases I almost made.


Sometimes I find something beautiful and expensive. I consider it. I imagine it in my home. I briefly contemplate the financial consequences.


Then I decide against it.


This gives me an enormous sense of restraint.


I did not spend $300 on that fireplace. I did not spend $450 on those chairs. I did not purchase the elaborate antique piece that would have required renting the moving truck before I'm actually moving. Look at all the money I’ve saved!


This is apparently how I now measure financial responsibility. Not by what I purchase, but by the increasingly extravagant things I manage not to purchase.


And then there are the sellers.


I have communicated with so many strangers that I have begun to lose track. Some are lovely. Some are difficult. Some disappear halfway through a conversation. Some agree to sell something and then become mysteriously unavailable. Some have furniture listed for months but apparently no interest in actually selling it.


I have become familiar with the peculiar emotional landscape of online secondhand commerce. The excitement of finding something perfect. The anxiety of waiting for a response. The satisfaction of an accepted offer. The disappointment of discovering that the item has already sold. The indignation of being ignored by someone who supposedly wants my money.


I have occasionally found myself checking my messages with the intensity of a woman awaiting important romantic correspondence. Except instead of a gentleman declaring his love, I am hoping that a stranger in Batavia will agree to sell me a buffet for $75.


And somehow, I find this equally thrilling.


Actually, there is a distinct advantage to the buffet.


If the seller accepts my offer, I know exactly where I stand. There is no wondering whether the buffet is emotionally available, interested in commitment, or secretly entertaining offers from several other women. (Although, given my experiences with Facebook Marketplace, I suppose that last possibility cannot be ruled out.)


Perhaps the most ridiculous part of all this is that I am still extremely careful about money in nearly every other area of my life. I will compare grocery prices. I will question an unexpected charge. I will calculate how much interest I am paying on a loan. I will think carefully before committing to an unnecessary expense.


But show me a beautiful antique dresser at a reasonable price, and suddenly I am a woman of considerable means. A patron of the decorative arts. A collector. A benefactor of elderly people attempting to empty their basements.


I am aware that the individual purchases add up. I am aware that gas costs money. I am aware that the time spent driving across Western New York has value. I am even aware that I may eventually reach a point where there is simply no more room for furniture.


But I also know that I am creating a home almost entirely from things that other people no longer wanted.


And I love that.


I love finding something beautiful for a fraction of what it would cost new. I love the craftsmanship of older furniture. I love imagining how everything will come together. I love knowing that my house will not look like a furniture showroom.


I have a budget. I have a plan. I have financial discipline. I am simply making an extraordinary number of exceptions.


Someday, I’ll be sitting in my beautiful, fully furnished house, surrounded by all the extraordinary bargains I’ve collected. I’ll admire the furniture, consider what it all would have cost new, and congratulate myself on my financial responsibility.


I may even add up how much I’ve saved.


How much I’ve spent, however, is really none of my business.

Hope, Anyway

On loss, possibility, and the courage to keep believing


I have spent a lot of time wishing I could be less hopeful.


Hope has not always been particularly kind to me.


Hope has made me refresh my email too many times. It has made me stare at my phone. It has made me imagine houses that were never going to be mine and relationships that were never going to become what I wanted them to be. It has made me picture futures so clearly that losing them felt almost like losing something real.


There have been job applications I was sure might be the one. Houses I walked through and immediately started mentally arranging furniture inside of. Men I let myself imagine beside me months or years into a future they had not actually promised.


I have gotten very good at building entire lives out of possibility. Sometimes I wish I were not. It would probably be easier to expect less.


There is a certain protection in assuming something will not work out. If you never let yourself imagine the house, then maybe losing the house hurts less. If you never let yourself believe the interview went well, the rejection email cannot surprise you. If you never start picturing what a relationship might become, then maybe you do not feel quite so foolish when it ends.


I understand the appeal of that. I have even tried it. I have told myself not to get excited. Not to read too much into something. Not to start planning. Not to let my mind run ahead of reality.


I am terrible at it.


Give me one promising possibility and apparently I am already mentally living six months in the future.


This has caused problems.


Hope can make me stay too long. It can make me focus on potential instead of what is actually happening. It can convince me that if I am patient enough, understanding enough, persistent enough... something will eventually become what I wanted it to be.


Sometimes it does not.


Sometimes the man does not change.


Sometimes the house goes to someone else.


Sometimes the job rejection arrives anyway.


Sometimes hope is just me standing in front of a closed door, convinced I heard something moving on the other side.


And still, I keep hoping.


That is what I have been thinking about lately. Because for all the ways hope has hurt me... it has also gotten me here.


I applied for nearly forty jobs because some part of me believed one of them could change my life.


I kept looking at houses after losing the ones I thought were supposed to be mine because some part of me still believed there might be another one.


I filled out the paperwork. I made the offers. I drove to towns I had barely heard of. I kept imagining bedrooms and bookshelves and Christmas mornings even after I had been disappointed enough times that cynicism would have been completely understandable.


Then one day, there was a house.


And this time, the answer was yes.


That is the problem with hope... sometimes it is right. Not about everything. Certainly not about everyone. But often enough. Often enough that I cannot quite convince myself to give it up.


I think I used to believe the lesson was supposed to be that I needed to stop getting my hopes up.


Maybe that is not it.


Maybe I need to get better at knowing what hope is allowed to do.


Hope can get me to apply. It can get me to make the offer. It can get me to try again. It can let me imagine something better than what I have now.


What it cannot do is turn potential into reality. It cannot make someone love me correctly. It cannot make the seller choose my offer. It cannot guarantee that the job is mine.


Hope is not evidence. That distinction has taken me longer to learn than I would like to admit. There is a difference between hoping something will happen and building my entire emotional life around the assumption that it will.


I am still learning where that line is.


But I do not think I want to become the kind of person who expects nothing just so nothing can disappoint her. There is simply too much of my life that exists because I kept believing something else might be possible.


The promotion. The house. The life I am building now. None of those things were guaranteed when I started reaching for them. They were possibilities.


And I reached anyway.


So maybe hope is not the problem.


Maybe hope is the reason I keep getting back up.


I have been disappointed by jobs I wanted, houses I loved, and people I believed in. I have watched futures disappear after I had already started imagining myself inside them. I have cried over things that never became mine.


And then, eventually, I tried again anyway. I sent another application. I walked through another house. I let myself like someone new.


Love has hurt me, sometimes badly. And somehow, I am still willing to believe in it. I used to think that made me foolish.


I do not anymore.


There is something brave about continuing to want things after wanting has hurt you. There is something brave about letting yourself imagine another possibility when the last one fell apart.


Hope has disappointed me plenty of times. But it has also kept me reaching.


And every once in a while, what I reached for reached back.


I have a promotion I once only hoped I would get. I'm buying a house I once only imagined. There are things in my life now that existed first only as possibilities I refused to stop believing in.


So I think I will keep hoping.


I think I will keep getting excited too soon sometimes. I will probably imagine futures that never happen. I will probably get hurt again. But I would rather be someone who keeps believing there could be something good ahead than someone who stopped reaching because she was afraid of being wrong.


I have lost enough to know hope can hurt.


I have gained enough to know it is still worth having.

Down to the Bone (One Minute Memoir)


A Memoir on Chicken Wings, Leftovers, and Unfinished Business

Setting: October 2026 — At home, with a container of Buffalo wings

Holden loves chicken wings. They’re one of his favorite foods, so when I went to Buffalo recently, I brought some home for him. It seemed only right to bring back chicken wings from the city that invented them.


One evening, we sat down together with the leftovers, picking through the container and claiming our favorites. We both prefer flats, naturally, so those tend to disappear first. Eventually, I finished eating and set my bones aside.


“Are you done with those?” Holden asked.


“Yes. Why?”


“There’s still a lot of meat on them. Let me have them.”


I looked down at the pile of chicken wing carcasses I’d just discarded. I had eaten those wings. I was quite certain of it. There might have been a few scraps here and there, but nothing that warranted further attention.


Holden disagreed.


I handed them over, and for the next fifteen minutes, I watched my eight-year-old son gnaw on the remains of my dinner.


He turned the bones over, worked his way around them, and somehow managed to keep finding more meat. He was remarkably thorough. I thought I’d done a perfectly acceptable job of eating my wings, but apparently I’d barely scratched the surface.


And this has since become something of a routine. Whenever we have chicken wings now, Holden wants to know whether I’m finished with mine. Not because he wants another whole wing, necessarily, but because he wants the bones of the wings I’ve already eaten.


My leftovers have leftovers.


I don’t know whether Holden is exceptionally good at eating chicken wings or I’m exceptionally bad at it. But there’s something humbling about watching your eight-year-old inspect your dinner scraps and decide you’ve left an unreasonable amount of food behind.


I’ve been eating chicken wings for decades.


Apparently, I’ve never actually finished one in my life.

This post is part of my One-Minute Memoir series — short reflections on small moments that still manage to say something big.

The Company I Keep

On fearing loneliness, finding independence, and learning to like the woman I’m alone with


There was a night, not so very long ago, when I sat in my bedroom at my parents’ house and cried because I was afraid I would never find someone to love me.

I had dating apps open on my phone. Several of them, actually. I had downloaded one, then another, then another, as though the problem might simply be that the right man was hiding on a platform I hadn’t discovered yet.

I swiped. I read profiles. I held conversations. I waited for replies. I wondered why someone hadn’t messaged back, why someone else had disappeared, why finding a decent man seemed to require more research than obtaining a federal mortgage. It had become practically a full-time job.

And I was miserable.

I remember feeling desperate. Not necessarily for any particular man, but for the certainty that there would eventually be one. Someone who would choose me. Someone who would stay. Someone who would make the future feel less frightening.

I had spent so much of my adult life believing that happiness required a partner. That being single was a temporary condition to be corrected as quickly as possible. That somewhere out there was a person I needed to find before I could finally relax and feel secure.

And sitting there in my parents’ house, staring at a screen full of strangers, I was terrified that I might never find him.

It wasn’t just loneliness. Loneliness I could understand. Loneliness was missing having someone to talk to at the end of the day, someone to hold me, someone who knew the small details of my life without having to be told. This was something bigger.

I was afraid of the future.

I couldn’t imagine growing older without a partner. I couldn’t imagine making all the decisions, carrying all the responsibilities, and navigating everything life might throw at me without another adult beside me. I couldn’t imagine that a life without romantic love could still be a happy one.

And so I searched.

I searched when I was tired. I searched when I was discouraged. I searched after disappointing dates and conversations that went nowhere. I searched even when the process itself was making me unhappy. Every new match represented a possibility. Every promising conversation offered a little relief. Maybe this one. Maybe this was the person who would finally make everything feel okay.

And every disappointment brought me back to the same frightening question.

What if there wasn’t anyone?

I wish I could tell you that something extraordinary happened that night. That I put down my phone, dried my tears, and suddenly understood that I was enough on my own.

I didn’t.

I probably kept swiping.

That’s the thing about becoming independent. At least for me, it wasn’t a dramatic declaration. It wasn’t a sudden realization accompanied by empowering music and an entirely new personality. It happened so gradually that I almost missed it.

There was no defining moment. No particular morning when I woke up and decided I was no longer afraid of being alone. I can’t point to a conversation, a date, or some profound realization that changed everything. I just slowly started living differently.

I stopped treating the dating apps like an obligation. I stopped feeling as though every evening without a conversation was another evening wasted. I started pausing my profiles when I didn’t feel like dating, deleting apps when they became exhausting, and returning when I actually wanted to meet someone. I came and went as I pleased.

This might not sound particularly remarkable, but for someone who once felt almost frantic about finding a partner, it was an enormous change. I no longer felt compelled to keep looking simply because I was afraid of what might happen if I stopped. I began to realize that I didn’t have to respond to every message. I didn’t have to pursue every possibility. I didn’t have to keep a conversation alive just because someone was willing to have one with me.

And I certainly didn’t have to convince myself to want someone simply because he wanted me. I could be selective. I could be uninterested. I could decide that I would rather spend an evening reading a book than making small talk with another stranger. I could decide that I didn’t want to date anyone at all for a while.

And nothing terrible happened.

The world kept turning. My life kept moving forward. The future didn’t suddenly become smaller because I wasn’t actively searching for someone to share it with.

In fact, it began to feel bigger.

Because somewhere in the middle of all this, I was building a life. I was raising my boys. Working. Writing. Making plans. Buying a house. Choosing furniture. Imagining holidays and ordinary evenings and all the little things I wanted our future to hold. I was making decisions that once would have frightened me. I was handling problems I didn’t know how to solve until I had no choice but to solve them. I was discovering that I could do difficult things without a partner beside me.

There have been moments when I’ve wished someone else could take over. When I’ve been tired of making decisions, tired of worrying, tired of being the person responsible for figuring everything out.

I don’t want to pretend that independence is always easy. Sometimes it’s exhausting. Sometimes I would love to hand someone a problem and say, “Here. You figure this one out.”

But I’ve also learned something about myself that I didn’t know before.

I can do it.

I can make the decisions. I can solve the problems. I can navigate the uncertainty. I can be scared and overwhelmed and completely unsure of what comes next, and I can keep going anyway. I’ve done it over and over again.

And the more capable I’ve become, the less frightening the future has started to feel. Not because I know exactly what it holds. But because I finally trust myself to handle it.

And perhaps most surprisingly, I’ve discovered that I actually enjoy my own company.

I like my routines. I like having time to read, write, watch television, or do absolutely nothing. I like deciding how to spend my evenings without having to consult anyone. I like the quiet. I like the freedom. I like being able to make plans and change them. I like not having to explain why I want to stay home. I like the small, ordinary pleasures of a life that belongs to me.

There was a time when I would have interpreted an evening alone as evidence that something was missing. Now, sometimes, it’s exactly what I want. I can spend an entire evening doing nothing particularly remarkable and feel perfectly content. I can read for hours. I can watch something ridiculous on television. I can write. I can browse antique furniture that I absolutely do not need and will probably attempt to purchase anyway. I can enjoy the simple pleasure of not having anywhere to be and nobody to impress.

And I don’t spend the entire time wondering why there isn’t a man beside me.

That’s new.

I think I spent so much time being afraid of ending up alone that I never considered the possibility that I might actually enjoy my own company. I had always imagined independence as something I would have to endure if I couldn’t find love. A consolation prize. A way of making the best of a situation I hadn’t wanted. I never imagined it might become something I genuinely valued. Something I might even be reluctant to give up.

Because somewhere along the way, the way I thought about relationships began to change.

I still want love. I still want companionship, affection, and someone to share the ordinary details of life with. I want someone who makes me laugh, who understands me, who wants to build something lasting together.

But I no longer want a relationship simply to avoid being alone. I want one because it adds something wonderful to a life I already love. And that changes everything. It changes how I date. It changes what I’m willing to accept. It changes how I respond when something doesn’t work out.

I can still be disappointed. I can still get my hopes up. I can still feel hurt when someone doesn’t choose me, or when a connection I was excited about turns into something less than I’d hoped. I’m not immune to any of that. But I no longer approach every new conversation as though my entire future depends on its outcome.

If someone doesn’t work out, I’m disappointed. Sometimes I’m hurt. Sometimes I wonder what happened or whether I did something wrong. But eventually, I return to my life.

And my life is still there.

The boys are still there. My work is still there. My books, my writing, my plans, my ridiculous collection of antique furniture. The home I’m building. The future I’m looking forward to. None of it disappears because a man doesn’t choose me.

I think that was something I needed a long time to understand.

For years, I imagined happiness as something I would eventually arrive at with another person. I thought I needed someone beside me to feel safe, secure, and complete. I thought being alone meant something had gone wrong. And perhaps that’s why the dating apps became so consuming. I wasn’t simply looking for someone I liked. I was looking for someone who could make the uncertainty go away. Someone who could reassure me that I wouldn’t be alone forever.

But no stranger on a dating app could have given me the kind of security I was searching for. Even if I’d met someone wonderful, I would still have needed to learn how to feel safe in my own life. I would still have needed to learn that I could stand on my own.

And somehow, without realizing it was happening, I did.

I bought a house on my own. I built a career. I made plans for my children. I started imagining a future that didn’t depend on whether someone else decided to be part of it. I began furnishing rooms for the life I wanted to live, not the life I hoped someone might eventually give me.

And somewhere along the way, the fear began to loosen its grip.

I don’t know exactly when it happened. I only know that the woman I am now feels different from the woman who sat crying in her bedroom, desperately swiping through dating apps because she couldn’t imagine being happy alone.

Sometimes I think about her.

I think about how scared she was. How desperately she wanted reassurance. How convinced she was that something essential was missing from her life. I wish I could go back and tell her what I know now.

That she would be okay.

That she would do things she never imagined doing alone. That she would discover strengths she didn’t know she had. That she would build a home and a future and a life that felt like her own. That she would still want love, but she wouldn’t need it to believe that good things were ahead.

And perhaps most surprisingly, that she would come to enjoy the very thing she was so afraid of.

Her own company.

I’m still sitting in that same bedroom at my parents’ house. So much around me looks the same. But I no longer spend my evenings desperately searching for proof that someone, somewhere, might want me.

I have things to do. Books to read. Stories to write. Children to raise. A house to turn into a home. Plans I’m excited about, with or without anyone beside me. 

I still want love in my life. I’ve simply learned that my life doesn't have to wait for it.

And the remarkable thing is that, while I was waiting for someone to share my life with, I was already building one worth living. It's happening in the home I'm creating, the children I'm raising, the stories I'm writing, and the future I'm imagining for myself. It's happening whether or not there's someone beside me to share it.

For so long, I'd been looking at my life in terms of what was missing. I hadn't given nearly as much thought to everything that was already there, and I'd given even less thought to the woman trying her best to hold it all together. 

Perhaps learning to appreciate the life I'd built was also teaching me something about the woman who had made it. I'd spent so long searching for someone whose company would make me happy, that I'd almost overlooked the person who had been here all along.

I'm still getting to know her. I'm still learning to appreciate her, to forgive her, and to be a little kinder to her.

And maybe, one day, I'll learn to love her the way I've always hoped someone else would.

The Widow of North Street

On Victorian fantasies, questionable acquisitions, and a husband who never existed


I am 37 years old, have never been widowed, and am inexplicably furnishing my home as though my wealthy husband died in 1893.


I don’t know exactly when this happened.


Until recently, my decorating style was decidedly country. Primitive furniture, Americana, rustic accents. I loved all of it. I spent years collecting things that made my first house feel warm and lived-in, with a distinctly old-fashioned farmhouse aesthetic.


And then, apparently, I changed centuries.


I no longer want to live in a farmhouse.


I want to live in a Victorian estate.


Preferably one with a substantial inheritance, a mysterious family history, and a housekeeper who knows things but refuses to discuss them. Unfortunately, my actual circumstances are somewhat less glamorous.


I am a single mother of two, employed by the State of New York, and purchasing an older house in a small Western New York town with the assistance of a USDA mortgage. There is no inheritance. There is no housekeeper. There is certainly no deceased wealthy husband. There is, however, a very ambitious decorating plan.


It began innocently enough.


The house has a room I intend to turn into a library. A real library, with bookshelves and antique chairs and a fireplace. I have always wanted one, and the prospect of having a room devoted entirely to books was almost enough to make me forget the considerable financial commitment involved in purchasing the rest of the house.


Naturally, I began looking for furniture.


And somewhere between searching for a bookshelf and discovering antique fireplaces, I lost all sense of proportion. I wanted carved wood. Ornate details. Brass accents. Rich colors. Furniture that looked as though it had survived several generations of family scandals.


I found a pair of magnificent Victorian chairs that I thought would look beautiful flanking the fireplace. They were enormous. My library, unfortunately, is not. It measures approximately nine and a half feet wide. This did not initially discourage me. I simply began exploring increasingly creative furniture arrangements, apparently operating under the assumption that the laws of geometry were more like suggestions.


I wanted the chairs. I wanted the fireplace. I wanted a room that looked as though an elderly aristocrat had spent forty years accumulating rare books and refusing visitors. What I had was a narrow room and a tape measure.


Reality is frequently disappointing.


I have also considered Victorian sofas, antique buffets, and various other pieces of furniture whose dimensions suggest they were designed for rooms considerably larger than mine. Some of these pieces do not even look particularly comfortable. This is apparently no longer a significant consideration.


I have reached a point in my decorating journey where I am willing to sacrifice lumbar support for historical atmosphere. I don’t necessarily want furniture that invites people to sit down. I want furniture that makes people feel they should ask permission first.


The deeper I ventured into Victorian decorating, the more particular I became. I didn’t want just any fireplace. I wanted one with character. I didn’t want furniture that looked new. I wanted furniture that looked as though it had witnessed things. A marriage. A death. An inheritance dispute. Possibly a scandal involving the gardener.


I also developed an alarming interest in antique objects whose original purposes are only vaguely familiar to me. Old typewriters. Ornate mirrors. Decorative fireplace screens. Brass fixtures. I recently found myself researching whether a typewriter would be historically appropriate in a Victorian library.


This is the sort of question that now occupies my evenings. Not whether the house has sufficient electrical outlets. Not whether I have remembered to arrange utilities. Whether the typewriter is historically accurate.


I have begun to suspect that I am taking this entire historical fantasy a little too seriously.


After all, I am not restoring a grand estate that has been in my family for generations. I am furnishing an ordinary house in Le Roy, New York. I will not be receiving callers in a drawing room or summoning a maid to bring tea. I will be answering emails, helping with homework, and asking Alexa to play music while I fold laundry.


And yet, I find myself considering whether a particular chair looks sufficiently aristocratic.


I imagine the widow of North Street would be a formidable woman. She would have excellent posture, an extensive personal library, and a reputation for being difficult to impress. She would wear elaborate dresses, maintain a small circle of acquaintances, and occasionally stare out the window with an expression suggesting that she knew considerably more about her husband’s death than she was willing to reveal.


She would certainly not tolerate cheap-looking furniture.


She would also probably have someone else responsible for moving it.


This is where our circumstances differ considerably.


My imaginary widow has servants. I have a small SUV, a tape measure, and an aunt with a truck. The widow can simply point at an enormous antique cabinet and instruct someone to place it beside the fireplace. I have to determine whether it will fit through a doorway, whether it can be transported without damaging the upholstery, and whether the seller is willing to answer a message.


The widow has inherited wealth.


I have a mortgage.


The widow has a grand estate.


I have a room that is nine and a half feet wide.


Nevertheless, I believe we share an appreciation for fine furnishings.


There is also the question of how this elaborate historical atmosphere will coexist with the actual people who live in the house. My children, for example, are unlikely to appreciate the distinction between an authentic Victorian antique and a piece of furniture that simply looks old. They will probably be more concerned with whether a chair is comfortable, whether the Wi-Fi works, and whether they are allowed to eat snacks in the library.


I can imagine myself explaining that a particular piece of furniture is quite old and should be treated carefully.


They will ask why I bought it.


I will explain that it has character.


They will ask whether they can put their feet on it.


The widow would undoubtedly be horrified.


I will probably tell them to take their shoes off.


And then there is the matter of my romantic prospects. A proper Victorian widow might spend her afternoons awaiting correspondence from a distinguished gentleman who owns a considerable amount of land.


I do not have a distinguished gentleman. I have several gentlemen on dating apps, which is arguably a more exhausting situation.


At least in 1893, a woman could reasonably expect a suitor to write a letter. Today, apparently, I am supposed to be impressed when a man sends a message containing three words and no punctuation.


Perhaps the widow had the right idea. Acquire a fortune, furnish the house beautifully, and spend the rest of one’s life reading books in peace.


Unfortunately, the fortune remains elusive.


I have also considered whether my sudden fascination with Victorian furnishings says something profound about my personality. Perhaps it represents a desire for stability, permanence, or a connection to the past. Perhaps I am drawn to the craftsmanship and history of objects that have survived longer than many modern relationships.


Or perhaps I have been possessed by the spirit of a nineteenth-century widow. At this point, I am keeping an open mind.


What I do know is that I am enjoying the entire ridiculous process. I love searching for unusual pieces, imagining their histories, and figuring out how to incorporate them into a house that was not designed to accommodate the furniture of the landed gentry. There is something particularly satisfying about finding an object that has already survived a century or more and giving it another place to belong.


Even if that place is considerably smaller than the one it was originally intended for.


Of course, the finished result will probably be less historically accurate than I imagine. My beautiful Victorian library will contain electrical outlets, modern lighting, and a phone charger. There will be no household staff. There will be no elaborate afternoon teas. There will almost certainly be a child sitting in an antique chair watching YouTube.


And I will be there, drinking a large McDonald’s Diet Coke, wearing sweatpants, and wondering whether the room could possibly accommodate one more piece of furniture.


I may not have inherited a fortune. I may not have married a wealthy gentleman. I may not even have enough room for all the furniture I want.


But I am determined to have a library worthy of a woman of considerable means, even if the woman in question is currently checking her bank account and negotiating with strangers on Facebook Marketplace.


And if the furniture is uncomfortable, the room is overcrowded, and absolutely nothing fits the way I imagined?


Well. 


Nobody ever said being a wealthy Victorian widow was easy.