It’s officially that time again: twinkle lights, predictable plotlines, and small towns that somehow look like snow globes. Every year, I dive headfirst into the cozy chaos of Christmas movie season, watching as many as I can from Hallmark, Great American Family, and beyond. These movies are hot cocoa for the brain — comforting, sweet, and a little bit corny — and I wouldn’t have it any other way. Here’s what I’ve been watching so far this season.
1. A Wisconsin Christmas Pie
Great American Family | 2025 | ★★★☆☆ | Watched: Oct 31
A pastry chef returns home for the holidays and finds her family’s cherry orchard on the brink of closure. Between reconnecting with her high school sweetheart and entering the local pie contest to recreate her grandmother’s famous recipe, she’s torn between her big-city career and small-town roots.
I watched this one on Halloween as the kickoff to my Christmas movie season, and it was the perfect start. It had all the right ingredients (pun intended): baking, family legacy, and a second-chance romance. The small-town setting was adorable, the community feel was strong, and the emotional pull around family and tradition gave it just enough depth. It’s exactly what I want from a Christmas movie: cozy, predictable, and just the right amount of cheesy.
2. A Royal Montana Christmas
Hallmark | 2025 | ★★☆☆☆ | Watched: Nov 2–3
Hallmark wouldn’t be Hallmark without at least one royal Christmas movie, and they kicked off the season with this one. A princess from a (naturally) fictional European country, overwhelmed by her royal duties, escapes to a Montana ranch she once visited as a child with her late father. There, she reconnects with the locals, helps save their popular Christmas dance, and begins to question what she really wants for her future.
I’ll admit it, the royal-themed Christmas movies are usually my least favorite. The made-up countries, questionable accents, and over-the-top fairy-tale plots always push things a little too far for me. While I did enjoy the western backdrop and the cozy community feel at the ranch, this one didn’t quite deliver. The romance lacked chemistry, the story dragged a bit, and it just didn’t have the spark of some of Hallmark’s best. Think Princess Diaries… but not nearly as fun.
3. A Prayer For Christmas
Great American Family | 2025 | ★★☆☆☆ | Watched: Nov 4
Children’s book illustrator Natalie is stuck in a creative rut until she discovers a little girl’s Christmas list unlike any other: a series of prayers asking Jesus to bless her family, friends, and widowed father. Moved by the girl’s kindness, Natalie quietly sets out to make each wish come true and rediscovers her own inspiration along the way.
This one was heartfelt and undeniably sweet, starring two familiar faces I’ve come to enjoy in Christmas movies (Shae Robins and Christopher Russell). The story delivered a beautiful message about kindness and faith, and the overall tone captured the spirit of the season. That said, it leaned much heavier into overt religious themes than I typically enjoy. While I appreciate Great American Family’s focus on wholesome storytelling, this one felt a bit too preachy for my taste. Still, it had warmth, charm, and sincerity... just not one I’d rush to rewatch.
4. A Christmas Angel Match
Hallmark | 2025 | ★★☆☆☆ | Watched: Nov 5–6
Two Christmas matchmaking angels are sent to Earth to help a pair of destined soulmates fall in love before Christmas. When the matchmaking department faces downsizing, they’re forced to work together despite their clashing styles: one by-the-book, the other spontaneous and full of holiday spirit. As their mission unfolds, they start to question whether they might be the ones meant to find love.
This was a cute movie, featuring one of Hallmark’s better leading men, Benjamin Ayres. I liked the unique concept and the mix of love connections woven throughout the story. That said, it fell a bit flat for me. I’m not big on fantasy-style plots, and this one leaned too far in that direction. It also missed that cozy small-town, community vibe I usually look for in my Christmas movies. Still, it had its moments of charm — just not enough to make it a standout this season.
5. Merry Christmas, Ted Cooper!
Hallmark | 2025 | ★★★★★ | Watched: Nov 7
After a string of unlucky holidays, cheerful weatherman Ted Cooper returns home to Lackawanna, NY, determined to make this Christmas a good one. A few accidents, and an Urgent Care visit later, he reconnects with old faces from high school, including a former crush who’s now a doctor. Despite his trademark bad luck, Ted might finally get the merry Christmas he’s been chasing all along.
This one was an absolute winner for me! It was funny and sweet, and Ted was completely endearing. I wasn’t familiar with Robert Buckley, who played Ted, but I absolutely loved him! He was charming, adorable, and genuinely likable. The romance felt realistic, the holiday cheer was abundant, and I’ll definitely be looking for more of his movies. Fun fact: I was thrilled to realize in the opening scene that it takes place in a city not far from me!
6. A Royal Icing Christmas
Great American Family | 2025 | ★☆☆☆☆ | Watched: Nov 9
Princess Charlotte of "Marovia" escapes her royal duties, and a pending arranged engagement, by sneaking off to a cozy New England town for Christmas. Hoping to rediscover herself, she enters a local baking competition and befriends Luke, whose family owns the inn where she’s staying. As sparks start to fly, she must decide whether to return to her royal life or follow her heart.
Another royal movie, and another thumbs down for me. This one had all the usual pitfalls: a fake kingdom, forced accents, and plenty of cheesy dialogue. I’ll give it credit for a fun premise (a secret escape! A baking competition!), but the execution just wasn’t there. The acting was rough across the board — the lead actress was fine, but everyone else struggled, especially the male lead. It’s hard to enjoy a movie when the performances pull you right out of it.
... and that wraps up my first six movies of the season! I plan on reviewing in batches like this every week or two, so LOTS more to come!